It's a Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play was the only play produced in Otterbein Summer Theatre's 2024 season. In a radio play set in the WBFR radio station, actors had to use solely their voices to tell the story of It's a Wonderful Life. McCracken played the character of Freddie Filmore, the station's host and one of their star voice actors, who voiced over 15 characters in the radio play, including Henry Potter, Joseph the Angel, Uncle Billy, Peter Bailey, Ernie the Cab Driver, and many others.